A fresh controversy has erupted in the ongoing West Indies vs Australia Test series, as WI head coach Daren Sammy confronted match referee Javagal Srinath over a string of contentious umpiring decisions during the first Test in Barbados. The flashpoint came after Day 2, when Sammy sought clarity on multiple calls made by TV umpire Adrian Holdstock, which the West Indies camp believes unfairly impacted the match.
⚖️ Two Key Decisions Spark Outrage
- Roston Chase’s LBW dismissal to Pat Cummins was upheld despite what appeared to be an inside edge, visible on UltraEdge
- Shai Hope’s catch behind was ruled clean by the third umpire, though replays suggested the ball may have touched the ground
“We are just trying to find some sort of understanding as to what the process is… We only hope for consistency,” Sammy told ESPNcricinfo, expressing frustration over what he called a pattern of questionable decisions.
🧭 Pattern of Concern: Not the First Time
Sammy also referenced similar issues with Holdstock’s officiating during the recent ODI series in England, where the South African umpire served both on-field and as TV umpire. He emphasized that the team is not seeking favoritism, but fair and consistent application of rules.
“You don’t want to go into a Test match not trusting the umpires… We’re just looking for clarity,” he added.
🗣️ Australia Also Raise Eyebrows
Interestingly, Australia’s Mitchell Starc also questioned the sync between visuals and audio during a Day 2 review, suggesting that both teams were affected by the inconsistencies.
📌 What’s Next?
- Sammy has not confirmed whether West Indies will lodge a formal complaint with the ICC
- The team remains focused on the match but has urged officials to review the decision-making process
- The controversy adds pressure on the ICC to reassess umpiring protocols and transparency
🔁 Share this article to follow the latest developments in the WI vs AUS Test series and the growing debate over umpiring standards.
